When the sky becomes a business corridor

I recently came across a news report about Amazon delivering packages by drone in Chicago's southern suburbs. Some residents welcomed the convenience, but others raised concerns about noise and safety.

My reaction was a little different. I wondered whether Amazon had the legal right to fly its drones over someone else's property without permission.

This is a question that may soon matter to businesses throughout Northwest Indiana. Drones offer possibilities beyond package delivery. Hospitals could use them to transport medical supplies. Contractors already use them to inspect buildings and construction sites. Utilities and property managers can survey facilities that would otherwise be difficult or expensive to inspect.

But using drones may involve flying over property owned by someone else. And the owners below may have their own legitimate interests in how that airspace is used.

In real estate practice, when a business needs to cross another owner's property, we ordinarily look for an easement, license or other legal authority. Aviation operates differently.

In 1927, the Indiana General Assembly adopted legislation declaring that ownership of airspace belongs to the owner of the land beneath it. That provision remains in effect as Indiana Code § 8-21-4-3.

But the next section establishes a qualified right of flight. Under Indiana Code § 8-21-4-4, aircraft generally may fly over private property without the owner's permission unless the flight occurs at such a low altitude that it interferes with the owner's existing use of the land or airspace above it or is conducted in a manner imminently dangerous to people or property below.

The law also makes an important distinction between flying over property and landing on it. Except for forced landings, an aircraft cannot lawfully land on another person's property without consent.

Consider a healthcare organization exploring drone deliveries between facilities. A proposed route might cross office buildings, parking lots, residential neighborhoods, and other privately owned property. The organization would not necessarily need permission from every landowner beneath the flight path.

But what if the drones repeatedly passed close to an occupied office building or outdoor commercial facility, creating substantial noise or disrupting activities there?

Indiana's statute does not establish a fixed altitude at which every flight becomes unlawful. A drone passing 50 feet above an undeveloped parcel may present very different concerns from one passing at the same height above an occupied building. The aircraft's altitude, frequency, manner of operation and actual interference with existing property uses may all matter.

The Federal Aviation Administration regulates aircraft (including commercial drone) operations, aviation safety and access to airspace. But compliance with federal aviation rules does not necessarily resolve every private property dispute arising from a flight. Conversely, federal law may limit a property owner's ability to restrict an otherwise authorized flight route.

The availability of a legal remedy is another unsettled question. If a drone strikes a building and causes damage, principles of civil liability may apply. Repeated low altitude flights that interfere with a property's use present more difficult questions involving trespass or nuisance. Indiana courts have not definitively resolved how those principles apply to routine commercial drone operations.

For businesses considering drone technology, the implications extend beyond purchasing equipment or obtaining regulatory approval. Proposed flight routes, neighboring property uses, landing arrangements and the potential for interference deserve attention before operations begin.

Ownership of commercial property includes legally recognized interests in the airspace above it, but not an unconditional right to exclude aircraft merely because they pass overhead.

A flight path that saves one business time and money may pass daily over another business's workplace. Indiana law recognizes interests on both sides, but it has yet to draw all the boundaries between them.

Author

  • Jon Schmaltz
    Partner - Burke Costanza & Carberry LLP

    Jon Schmaltz is the practice group leader of the business and personal services practice group at Burke Costanza & Carberry LLP. With over 25 years of experience, Schmaltz represents mid-sized businesses, family-owned enterprises, financial institutions, private equity investors and real estate developers in complex business transactions, corporate structuring and financial deals. His business-minded, creative, and detail-focused approach allows him to develop strategic solutions tailored to each client’s objectives.

    View all posts

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top